Skip to main content

Making Threaded Google+ Hosted Comments Work

For many years, threaded comments was a frequently requested Blogger feature.

That option was finally added in 2012. When Blogger added Google+ hosted comments in 2013, threaded Google+ commenting was later added.

Threaded comments, provided as an option in Blogger hosted comments, have significant requirements. Google+ hosted comments have additional requirements - and predictably, threaded comments in Google+ hosted comments have still more requirements.

We have explored the ownership issues of Google+ hosted comments, and similarly, visibility issues.

Google+ Comments involve issues of Google+, and of commenting in general.

In making Google+ hosted threaded comments work properly, one must consider the requirements of Google+, Google+ Comments, and Threaded Comments together. And do not overlook the need for authentication - and proper cookie filtering required for commenting, in general.

Finally, to have a commenting based conversation, you need a relationship between the two parties in the conversation. That relationship, in Google+, is provided by Following, or Circling.

Non public Google+ comments involve circle membership.

Visibility of a Google+ hosted comment, when not published Publicly, requires that the person publishing a comment to have Circled anybody who will read the comment. The ability of someone to reply, in a threaded comment, then requires both parties to have Followed, or Circled each other.

Additionally, since comments (in Google+ hosted commenting) are treated as posts (in Google+ Streams), comment replies (in Google+ hosted commenting) are treated as comments (in Google+ Streams). The publisher of a Google+ Stream post (Google+ hosted Blogger comment) owns the Stream post (Blogger comment) - and controls the settings for that post (comment).

Google+ Commenting involves membership and control issues.

Ownership of a Google+ hosted Blogger comment is the opposite of a Blogger hosted Blogger comment.

With the latter, all comments are owned by the blog owner. With the former, each comment is owned by the comment publisher - except replies are owned by the person publishing the reply (who might be the blog owner, or just as likely a third party).

This complexity is one possible reason why comment moderation is a community based process.


Popular posts from this blog

Adding A Link To Your Blog Post

Occasionally, you see a very odd, cryptic complaint I just added a link in my blog, but the link vanished! No, it wasn't your imagination.

What's The URL Of My Blog?

We see the plea for help, periodically I need the URL of my blog, so I can give it to my friends. Help! Who's buried in Grant's Tomb, after all? No Chuck, be polite. OK, OK. The title of this blog is "The Real Blogger Status", and the title of this post is "What's The URL Of My Blog?".

Embedded Comments And Main Page View

The option to display comments, embedded below the post, was made a blog option relatively recently. This was a long requested feature - and many bloggers added it to their blogs, as soon as the option was presented to us. Some blog owners like this feature so much, that they request it to be visible when the blog is opened, in main page view. I would like all comments, and the comment form, to be shown underneath the relevant post, automatically, for everyone to read without clicking on the number of comments link. And this is not how embedded comments work.