Skip to main content

Shall I Move My Blog, To Google+ Hosted Comments?

Just about 2 years ago (give or take a few days), I evaluated Google+ hosted comments, based on moderation / notification options.

A few changes have been made to Blogger - and to Google+ - since then. Some changes affect usefulness of Google+ hosted comments, in Blogger blogs.

I guess to honestly evaluate Google+ hosted comments, I should decide whether to leave this blog using Blogger hosted comments - or move forward.

Periodically, I muse about changing this blog, to use Google+ hosted comments.

I think the decision, of Blogger hosted comments vs Google+ hosted comments, comes down to choice. And, what content and features do you get with one, that you do not get with the other.

Choices for control of content.

With Blogger hosted comments, you can choose comment authentication, comment form location, moderation, and notification. All of these choices give you tools to control comments, in your blog - before, or after, they are published.

Google+ hosted comments give you one choice - comment form location. Everybody authenticates using a Google+ account. Blog owners do not choose commenters, or readers, based on authentication - and have no choices for moderation, or notification.

Choices for distribution of content.
Blogger hosted comments give you a wide complement of subscription choices - using either email or newsfeeds. Google+ hosted comments have neither.

Google+ does give marginally more choice for private blogs - or at least private content distribution - though many options may not involve publishing a Blogger blog.

Control of comments, and of readers.

Google+ hosted comments use community based moderation. You have no control over comments, posted to your blog, more than any other reader of the blog (who can see the comments).

You cannot moderate comments, so you have no need for moderation email. You are notified of comments - but notification relates to who is publishing comments (and you see all of their comments, against your blog and any others targeted by those who you follow), instead of helping you monitor everybody publishing comments against your blog.

Ability to view existing comments.

You can either display Blogger hosted comments - or Google+ hosted comments - on your blog. If you choose Blogger hosted comments, you can view comments on the blog, on your dashboard, and in your email, And you can view any Google+ hosted comments, published by anybody who you follow, in your Google+ stream.

If you choose Google+ hosted comments, you can view Google+ hosted comments on your blog, published by anybody who you follow - or in your Google+ stream. You won't be able to view Blogger comments, period, Old Blogger hosted comments are gone - and there won't be any new Blogger hosted comments.

Reader community commenting options.

With Blogger hosted comments, you can have readers who can comment using Blogger (onto the blog) - and other readers who can comment using Google+ (into their and your streams), With Google+ hosted comments, you'll have only readers who can comment, using Google+.

Comments based newsfeed.

With Blogger hosted comments, you have a Blogger comments newsfeed - and some comments published into the Google+ stream. With Google+ hosted comments, you have only the Google+ stream.

Visibility of comments.

With Blogger hosted comments, you can see all Blogger hosted comments, related to the blog, on the blog, in your dashboard, and in your email (when setup). You can also see Google+ hosted comments, from people who you follow, in your Google+ stream,

With Google+ hosted comments, you can see Google+ hosted comments, from people who you follow and who follow you, in your Google+ stream. You can't see existing Blogger hosted comments - and you won't get any new Blogger hosted comments. The visibility issue causes some confusion, from time to time.

Private content distribution.

With Blogger blogs and Blogger hosted comments, and considering recent private blog access changes, private content distribution is somewhat limited - for large groups of people. Google+ - and Google+ hosted comments - will support groups of unlimited size.

The bottom line.

So having reasoned all of that out, I still see no advantage of using Google+ hosted comments, exclusively, in this blog. People who publish private blogs, with large reader populations, may see things differently.


Selby Evans said…
I evaluated that issue when the option first appeared. I have a public blog. My conclusion was that G+ hosted comments are not a good choice for a public blog.
Nitecruzr said…
Hi Selby,

Thanks for your observation!

I'm an optimist - and it seemed to me that, given 2 years to make it better, Blogger would surely find a way to make Google+ hosted comments less "all or nothing". But noooo, you can have Blogger hosted comments, or Google+ hosted comments - but not both.

Unless of course you stay with Blogger hosted comments. So, that's where this blog is.

Anybody wants to comment on this blog, using Google+ comments, can use their Google account, and post a Blogger hosted comment, here. Or, they can find one of my blog posts in their stream, and comment there.
Hi Chuck - I wonder if you can help ... some of my commenters struggle to leave comments - others manage, but I also find sometimes the comment doesn't go through on other blogs, when I'm leaving a comment.

I've checked spam, and awaiting moderation - albeit I don't use that, except occasionally ..

Any ideas ... ? Thanks so much - I'll be back to check anon ... Happy New Year and cheers - Hilary

Popular posts from this blog

Adding A Link To Your Blog Post

Occasionally, you see a very odd, cryptic complaint I just added a link in my blog, but the link vanished! No, it wasn't your imagination.

What's The URL Of My Blog?

We see the plea for help, periodically I need the URL of my blog, so I can give it to my friends. Help! Who's buried in Grant's Tomb, after all? No Chuck, be polite. OK, OK. The title of this blog is "The Real Blogger Status", and the title of this post is "What's The URL Of My Blog?".

Embedded Comments And Main Page View

The option to display comments, embedded below the post, was made a blog option relatively recently. This was a long requested feature - and many bloggers added it to their blogs, as soon as the option was presented to us. Some blog owners like this feature so much, that they request it to be visible when the blog is opened, in main page view. I would like all comments, and the comment form, to be shown underneath the relevant post, automatically, for everyone to read without clicking on the number of comments link. And this is not how embedded comments work.